Climate Models Have Greatly Overstated Greenland Meltwater Runoff.
A new paper in Nature Communications exposes a major flaw in how climate models simulate Greenland’s runoff.
Cap Allon
Date: 2 October 2025
For decades, once seasonal snow melted, models assumed the exposed “bare ice” was impermeable—so every drop of meltwater was credited directly to the sea.
Field evidence now shows that assumption is wrong. Much of Greenland’s bare ice is porous, with a near-surface “weathering crust” that stores meltwater during the day and refreezes it at night. This overlooked process reduces actual runoff well below model output.
The study tested the idea in southwest Greenland—a sector that produces a large share of the ice sheet’s surface melt—using in-situ discharge measurements and two process models. One (“SkinModel”) emulated the standard impermeable-ice assumption. The other (“IceModel”) incorporated subsurface heating, porosity, and refreezing.
IceModel aligned with real-world discharge; SkinModel and existing regional models did not.
Multiple lines of evidence point to the same conclusion. Field discharge data show that supraglacial runoff has been overstated by 21–58% in peak summer. Satellite gravity (GRACE) indicates runoff-driven mass loss was exaggerated by 21–47%, while altimetry shows surface thinning overstated by 14–40%. Supraglacial lake infill rates near the snowline reveal even larger biases, in the range of 58–81%.
Gigatonnes
In southwest Greenland alone, between 11 and 17 gigatonnes per year of meltwater were retained and refrozen in bare ice between 2009–2018—around 9–15% of that sector’s modeled runoff. Extending the melt season raises the estimate to ~17 Gt. Since more than three-quarters of Greenland’s modeled runoff originates in bare-ice zones, this missing physics is not a minor detail—it is central.
The mechanism plays out like this: Daytime sunlight penetrates about a meter into impurity-laden bare ice, creating a water-saturated layer with measured density around 681 kg/m³—far below the 900 kg/m³ assumed by modern models. With horizontal water flow very limited, much of this liquid persists until evening, when surface air often drops to -5 to -6 C. At that point, refreezing rates approach 1 mm per hour, locking in meltwater that models had already counted as runoff.
Figure: Field data versus models. Observations in southwest Greenland show porous bare ice retains water, aligning with IceModel. The standard impermeable-ice assumption (green) overpredicts surface loss and misses subsurface storage. Cooper et al., (2025).
Models have been consistently overshooting how much water actually leaves the ice sheet—often by more than half—because they fail to capture porous ice storage and nocturnal refreezing.
The authors stress that bare-ice refreezing is a buffer, not a brake. Greenland is still melting, but far less than models have assumed. Widely used climate models have been inflating runoff, particularly in peak summer, and projections built on those errors cannot be taken at face value.
For decades, Greenland has been cast as the ultimate climate “tipping point.” If its runoff has been overstated by such margins, then confidence in sea-level forecasts—and in the models that drive policy—demands re-examination.
Cap Allon is the owner of the website Electroverse.info which is now also available on Substack. It pays a lot of attention to cold anomalies around the world. This article was written for the Clintel website.
more news
Nobel Prize winner Dr. John F. Clauser signs the Clintel World Climate Declaration
Nobel Prize winner Dr. John F. Clauser signs the Clintel World Climate Declaration John F. Clauser, winner of the 2022 Nobel Prize in Physics for his work on quantum mechanics, has decided to sign the World Climate Declaration of Clintel with its central message “there is no climate emergency”. Clauser is the second Nobel Laureate to [...]
Solar Activity: Cycle 25 Surpasses Cycle 24
Solar Activity: Cycle 25 Surpasses Cycle 24 By Javier Vinós reposted from Andy May Petrophysicist Over the past two decades, solar activity has been characterized by an extended solar minimum spanning two solar cycles, known as the Clilverd Minimum. This phenomenon is currently affecting the climate, but before we can understand its impact, [...]
Robin Hood, Climate, Class War and the Corruption of Science
Robin Hood, Climate, Class War and the Corruption of Science Robin Hood fought the ruling class and its representative, the corrupt and tyrannical Sheriff of Nottingham. The common folk of London today seem to face a similar oppression, this time under an environmentalist sheriff (mayor). The contexts are vastly different but the [...]
